The Scotch Game, an Opening London Played First
By Cameron W. · Fri, 20 Nov 2026
The Scotch was first played by London, not the Scots. From a horse-and-carriage match in 1824 to Kasparov’s 1990 revival, here’s its story.
There is a lovely irony at the heart of the Scotch Game. The opening that carries Scotland's name was, by Edinburgh's own account, first played in the famous match by London. The Edinburgh players liked it so much that, after fierce discussion, they adopted it themselves. Then it spent most of the twentieth century on the shelf, until a world champion walked into a title match and took it down again.
An Italian idea
The first author credited with mentioning what we now call the Scotch is Ercole del Rio, in his 1750 treatise by an anonymous Modenese author. The idea could not be simpler. After 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6, White plays 3.d4 and challenges the centre at once. No slow build-up and no quiet manoeuvring: White offers to open the position and asks Black what he plans to do about it.
Two clubs and a very slow match
The name comes from a correspondence match. The Edinburgh Chess Club, formed only two years earlier, cheekily challenged the far more established London Chess Club in 1824, with moves carried between the cities by horse and carriage. Edinburgh won the match 2-1, draws not counting, and it saw the introduction of the Scotch Game. The match ran for years, and the idea of 3.d4 was first used by the London side. History tends to hand the name to the side that won the argument rather than the side that started it.
The age of fireworks
The nineteenth century loved the Scotch. Howard Staunton played the Göring Gambit, 4.c3, at a high level in the 1840s, and the earliest known game with it is probably from 1843. Meek against Morphy in 1857 is the first known game with the gambit accepted, and Eugen von Schmidt recorded 4...Nf6 in 1865. Carl Göring brought the gambit into master play in 1872. Then came Jacques Mieses, who used 6.e5 again and again at Hastings 1895, including a first-round win over Blackburne, and the variation carries his name. Wilhelm Steinitz popularised the queen sortie 4...Qh4 for Black.
Out of fashion
By 1900 the Scotch had declined, because many thought White released the central tension too early and let Black equalise easily. The Ruy Lopez took over as the serious choice, and through the twentieth century the Scotch was played only sporadically and never really as a main opening at the highest level.
Kasparov changes the conversation
Then came 1990. With the score level in Game 14 of his World Championship match against Karpov, in Lyon and New York, Kasparov opened with the Scotch. It surprised everyone. He went on to lead a revival of the opening, arguing it caused Black lasting strategic problems while avoiding the heavily analysed Ruy Lopez. Chess.com credits the fifth move he used in that match, 5.Nxc6 in the Schmidt Variation, with making the Scotch popular again. Think about the nerve of that: an opening dismissed as a relic, played in a world title match.
Still testing the best
The revival did not stop with Kasparov. In the 2000s Vassily Ivanchuk and Magnus Carlsen brought back the Potter Variation with 5.Nb3, with success. Jan Timman and Sergei Rublevsky have also advocated the opening, and Kasparov's Mieses Variation games are cited among the most testing lines.
That is the secret of the Scotch. It asks a direct question on move three and does not bury you in theory before you have had a chance to play chess. Two cities, a horse and carriage, and a very long wait for the answer: not a bad story for an opening that still has plenty to say.
Sources
- Wikipedia, "Scotch Game"
- Chess.com, "Scotch Game" opening page
- ChessBase, "Scotch Game" (Openings)
- ChessBase, "Kasparov's Experiment" (Mieses Variation)
- ChessBase, "The Edinburgh Chess Club celebrates its 200th anniversary"
- Edinburgh Chess Club, "Club History, part 2"
- The Washington Times, "Chess bicentennial: remembering when Londoners got..." (13 Feb 2024)
- The Spectator archive, Raymond Keene, 6 April 1991
- Lichess, "Scotch Game